WAKE UP DEAD MAN Review: Everyone Has A Motive. No One Has An Alibi

Introduction

Have you ever found yourself experiencing a profound crisis of faith? Not just in a religious context, but perhaps questioning love or grappling with the reasons behind a significant life decision? These are complex emotions that Rian Johnson’s latest film, Wake Up Dead Man, navigates with exceptional skill. This film, the newest installment in the Knives Out series, featuring the ever-dashing detective Benoit Blanc (Daniel Craig), brings to the forefront the intricate nature of our doubts and beliefs.

Synopsis

Wake Up Dead Man is set in the quaint, atmospheric setting of Our Lady of Perpetual Fortitude, a small Catholic church where Father Jud has been newly assigned. His role is to assist the enigmatic Monsignor Jefferson Wicks (Josh Brolin), whose fiery, divisive sermons have alienated most parishioners, save for a loyal core group.

This ensemble cast includes Martha, the steadfast believer, brought to life by the always-impressive Glenn Close. Then there’s Vera (Kerry Washington), who remains tied to Wicks out of familial loyalty. There’s also Lee (Andrew Scott), an author who falls under the monsignor’s sway.

Wake Up Dead Man
Josh O’Connor and Daniel Craig star in “Wake Up Dead Man” (2025)—photo courtesy of Netflix.

Another intriguing character is Simone (Cailee Spaeny), who is desperately seeking a miracle to heal her ailments. Jeremy Renner, as Dr. Nat, delivers a poignant performance as a man shattered by personal loss and desperately trying to piece together his fractured life. Rounding out the group is the caretaker, Samson (Thomas Haden Church), fiercely loyal to Wicks for helping him overcome alcoholism, his commitment all the more poignant against the backdrop of his recovery journey.

However, the tranquility shatters when a catastrophic event unfolds during Monsignor Wicks’ Good Friday service, casting suspicion on these dynamic characters. Each becomes a potential suspect and a witness, with the truth of their involvement clouded by personal biases and hidden motives. Enter Detective Benoit Blanc, summoned by the overwhelmed local sheriff, Geraldine Scott (Mila Kunis), to untangle this web of mystery, setting the stage for yet another thrilling “whodunnit” adventure in true Agatha Christie style.

Discussion

This installment doesn’t just stand out for its gripping narrative; it delves deeply into the characters’ personal crises of faith. Johnson masterfully intertwines these individual stories, urging audiences to explore what drives our most profound beliefs and doubts. The script is nothing short of masterful, drawing us into a story so engaging and tension-filled that it feels almost like laying out the pieces of a complex puzzle. Benoit Blanc, this time around, is shown grappling with more personal qualms, a fascinating evolution for Craig’s charismatic detective.

Visually, the film is stunning. Shot amidst the breathtaking Herefordshire countryside, it evokes a sense of Hitchcockian suspense, using its lush backdrop to elevate the mystery. While the church itself might appear more akin to a Church of England edifice than an American Catholic one, its presence adds a haunting beauty that complements the film’s thematic undercurrents. The cinematography here stands out in its ability to draw viewers into the eerie, sodden woods, adding depth and texture to the overall atmosphere.

Further Analysis

As for the performances, the ensemble cast delivers exceptional work across the board. Glenn Close, Josh Brolin, and Mila Kunis each deliver nuanced performances that enrich the film. However, it’s Daniel Craig and Josh O’Connor who truly capture the spotlight. Craig’s portrayal of Blanc is both familiar and refreshing.

He introduces a vulnerability to Blanc’s otherwise confident demeanor, suggesting an underlying introspection that enriches the character. Meanwhile, O’Connor as Father Jud anchors the film with his complex portrayal of a man wrestling with faith and identity, delivering a nuanced performance that resonates deeply.

One of the most captivating aspects of this film, as with other Rian Johnson creations, is how richly it rewards multiple viewings. Each time you watch, you uncover new insights and layers, something akin to revisiting a favorite Agatha Christie novel, where the depth only enhances upon deeper inspection. Wake Up Dead Man promises exactly this: a film that doesn’t just tell a story but invites you into its world repeatedly, each visit offering something new.

Wake Up Dead Man
(L-R) Andrew Scott, Mila Kunis, Daryl McCormack, Glenn Close, Cailee Spaeny, and Kerry Washington star in “Wake Up Dead Man” (2025)—photo courtesy of Netflix.

Conclusion

While Wake Up Dead Man is slated for Netflix streaming, I would highly encourage experiencing its full grandeur in a theater setting. The sweeping visuals and intricate sound design demand the immersive atmosphere a theater provides, ensuring the viewer absorbs every carefully crafted detail. Don’t miss the opportunity to see it on the big screen, where Rian Johnson’s cinematic magic can be truly appreciated in all its splendor.

Wake Up Dead Man was released in select theaters on November 26, 2025, and will stream on Netflix starting December 12.

More from Cinema Scholars

SCREAM VI: There Are Rules Here? Oh No…There Are No Rules Here

PUNCH: Actor Jordan Oosterhof Talks About His New Sports/Drama

Keep up with Cinema Scholars on social media. Like us on Facebook, subscribe on YouTube, and follow us on Twitter, Threads, Instagram, and Bluesky