I recently watched Obsession with my son. During the film, I jokingly said what I thought a character was going to say next. My son was annoyed with me when the character proceeded to repeat verbatim what I had just said. I swear I wasn’t actually trying to predict anything. It’s not my fault Obsession was a paint-by-numbers story. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is like the full-length version of that moment.
The film unfolded much as I thought it would. Specifically, how Haymitch Abernathy came to be part of the resistance. I’m not trying to pat myself on the back for correctly predicting the plot of this latest installment. First, it’s a prequel. Second, it’s a prequel featuring an already established character (Haymitch). Third, the previews and movie posters made sure we knew the movie would revolve around a young Haymitch as a tribute in the Hunger Games. Thanks to the original trilogy, we already knew he won those games. So, how else were the writers going to add drama to this film?
The movie is so predictable because it suffers from the same restriction as many, many other sequels and prequels. It’s trapped in its own formula. The first movie and book were immensely popular primarily because of the literal Hunger Games. It isn’t an accident that the least popular entry in the franchise – Mockingjay – is also the only one that doesn’t feature any actual games (yes, I know the assault on the Capitol is a de facto version of the games). That’s why this film, as well as the other prequel, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, both revolve around a Hunger Games. Despite the entire franchise being a commentary on authoritarianism, audiences are more interested in murder arenas.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping also falls into the trap of focusing on a known character because he’s popular, not because he’s particularly interesting. We don’t need an entire movie to be convinced that a guy from the poorest and worst-treated district in the entire nation would join a rebellion against his oppressors. That’s why the movie throws all kinds of little twists at us to try to spice it up. Girlfriends, bright colors, volcanoes, younger versions of other characters, and nightmare Glenn Close. None of those things have anything to do with the rebellion…except one – Plutarch Heavensbee.
If the franchise wasn’t so beholden to featuring underdogs winning the Hunger Games, this film would have made Plutarch (Jesse Plemons) the main character. The kicker is the movie could still have included Haymitch (Joseph Zada) competing in the games and plenty of scenes within the games. But Plutarch is a much more compelling character to explore because he doesn’t come from a place of destitution and poverty. He’s an elite from the Capitol who has no obvious reason to want to change things.
On the plus side, it’s still a solid, entertaining movie. Despite the limitations described above, Haymitch gets a good backstory worthy of empathy. Plutarch also gets a fair amount of development. The high points of the film are when Haymitch and Plutarch are in the same room. Mckenna Grace also shines as fellow District 12 tribute Maysilee Donner. The film wisely resists turning her into a love interest for Haymitch. I also didn’t mind the inclusion of several other known characters, though they did feel a bit forced in the name of fan service.
Actually, there were two characters I did mind. Not for their inclusion, but for the way their characters diverged from their portrayals in earlier films. One is Caesar Flickerman (Kieran Culkin), the host of the Hunger Games. In the original trilogy, he was kind of a likeable character who genuinely seemed to feel a tinge of sadness at children dying. Not enough to bother him, but at least he noticed. Conversely, Culkin’s Caesar seems to delight in the misery of others, whether they be tributes in the games or coworkers on the show. Unless Caesar is bipolar, this contradiction doesn’t square.
Same goes for Effie Trinket, the Capitol representative assigned to oversee District 12’s tributes. When we originally met her in The Hunger Games, she was a self-absorbed twit, a little mean, and concerned only with pleasing President Snow. In Sunrise, she (Elle Fanning) is an ambitious, likeable fashionista, already winking at tributes that she is on their side. Like with Caesar, it’s a jarring change that doesn’t make any sense.
But again, I was entertained by Sunrise, even with how predictable much of it was. I would have liked to have seen a little more Ralph Fiennes (portraying Snow) and tied up Glenn Close’s character in some way (she has Effie’s job before Effie shows up late in the film and just vanishes), but the movie was already bordering on too long (158 minutes). Nothing that happened in the film surprised me, but at least I didn’t guess exactly what characters would say. My son hates when I do that.
